Vader then told the clone troopers that the galaxy belonged to him now. I believe that had Anakin made a hasty decision, disposing of Palpatine, that he would still fall to the dark side, just as it is said if Luke were to have killed him on DS2. This falls in line with Palpatine knowing that Padm was still alive after Anakin Force-choked her. The life Anakin could have had, the one where he might have been taken away from Star Wars' Jedi Order by Qui-Gon because of the council's refusal to let him . Unlike the golden protocol droid, R2-D2 never had a full memory wipe, so he was well aware of all events that happened around him. Curiously, when he was writing the script of Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith, George Lucas toyed with the idea of having the Sith be responsible for the death of Anakin's mother Shmi Skywalker. According to Cliegg Lars, a hunting party came out of nowhere and kidnapped her, taking her prisoner. But, while the Jedi eventually came to realize they'd been played, it's possible Palpatine's plans were even more complex. Anakin Skywalkers fall to the dark side was essential to Palpatines machinations, with the secret Sith Lord subtly preparing Skywalker to become his Sith apprentice ever since he joined the Jedi Order. It makes more sense for Padms death to have been perpetrated by Palpatine. The Clones true purpose, destroying the Jedi, would also need to be mitigated, with their control chip implants needing to be removed in canon and their indoctrination needing to be somehow reversed in Legends. While Anakin would later tell Palpatine about his attack on the Tusken Raiders, Palpatine very readily uses it as a point of manipulation against Anakin, to convince him to give into his violent urges once again. For one, the Empire at large underestimates and misunderstands Tusken Raider culture. I've haven't given it too much thought before. One such pivotal moment is the duel between Darth Vader and Obi-Wan Kenobi on Mustafar at the end of Revenge of the Sith. Anakin accompanied Obi-Wan on what he believed would be one final mission, and it culminated in a moment where Obi-Wan summoned the full force of the Republic to deal with the crisis. In one early draft, Palpatine pushed Anakin to do the deed by revealing Dooku had paid the Tusken Raiders to kidnap and kill Shmi. One might wonder how different things would have been had pivotal moments in the saga gone differently. Anakin looked at whats left of his master, as he force pushed the remains into the lava, burning away any last bit of love that was left for his former Master. The theory ran that Palpatine knew Plagueis' secrets, and used them to conceive . Written for The Mary Sue, ScreenRant, The Anime Feminist, The Gamer, and Vocal. Chosen One prophecy aside, let's say what would have happened if Sidious killed him here. Which leads to the other aspect of the theory suggesting the Tusken Raiders were framed. "Anakin alright. According to Anakin's mother Shmi, he had no natural father, a fact that made Qui-Gon Jinn very curious indeed. With this incident, maybe he would have gone mad and unleashed the power of the dark side against Sidious upon his arrival. In fact, there are hints that he may have been subconsciously subverting the Empire for the entirety of the original. READ NEXT: Star Wars Theory: What If The Emperor Won In 'Return Of The Jedi'? !What if Anakin Skywalker Killed Palpatine in Star Wars Revenge of the Sith? The cruel irony of Anakins choice is that she likely wouldnt have died if hed remained a Jedi. Related: Palpatine's Contingency Plan To Kill Vader: Order 151 Explained (In Legends). He uses the dark side to fight Windu, he is fueled by all his anger and hatred. GivenStar Wars 9 is calledThe Rise of Skywalker, it's safe to assume Palpatine will somehow be defeated by the Chosen One's legacy. ?This one is a little more analytical than just action pack. The vision changed, showing Palpatine's shroud encircled her, his hands curled in Sith sorcery, a swirl of dark side energy forming in Shmi's womb. And in one last stand to protect his children, Anakin would have tried to strike down Sidious if he were the one who arrived. Was Shmi Skywalker's death in Attack of the Clones just a stroke of luck for Palpatine - or did Darth Sidious actually engineer it? He's already planning on making Anakin his apprentice long before he disposes of Dooku. By eliminating her, Palpatine would be the only one left for Anakin to turn to and therefore would have complete control over him. Obi-Wan, who struggled with an attachment like Anakin in both canon and Legends, could be the one to lead these reforms, perhaps even replacing Yoda as the new Jedi Grandmasterin the long run. Anakin would then pledge himself to the dark side and was thus named Darth . When the Mandalorian and Toro Calican ask for permission to cross the Dune Sea, they request to barter. After killing Kenobi, he likely would have gone to check up on her right away. As the sun slowly rises over the landscape of Coruscant, Anakin Skywalker opens his eyes and looks around, seeing his wife asleep beside him. "A Chosen One shall come," the prophecy reads, "born of no father, and through him will ultimate balance in the Force be restored." A lot is happening in the galaxy during the time of the show, as according to Disney "The story begins 10 years after the dramatic events of Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith where Kenobi faced his greatest defeat, the downfall and corruption of his best friend and Jedi apprentice, Anakin Skywalker turned evil Sith Lord Darth Vader." In Revenge of the Sith, after a now Sith Anakin Skywalker is defeated by his former master Obi-Wan Kenobi, he is taken by Palpatine to be put into his Darth Vader suit to save his life. This view neatly explains why Palpatine wasn't exactly your ordinary Sith. Related: How Count Dooku Turned The Galaxy Against The Republic. Listen as we uncover more details about Anakin's reaction to Plagueis cheating death and what Anakin actually did next as he pondered this incredible news. On the other hand, perhaps seeing Anakin repent and trying to save her and the babies would have been enough to keep her fighting for life. What if Darth Plagueis killed Emperor Palpatine / Darth Sidious? In the same way, Sidious could well have been keeping an eye on Shmi as a potential tool to be used against Anakin, and he would therefore have become aware of her capture. The one who gives this diagnosis is a droid, and droids know relatively little about the Force. What if Anakin Beat Obi-Wan and Palpatine Beat Yoda - Star Wars Theory Star Wars Theory 3.3M subscribers Join Subscribe 22K Share Save 465K views 9 months ago This video is. Chapter 18- A New Path. This leads to the final element of the theory: did Palpatine manipulate the Tusken Raiders to attack Shmi, in particular, using the Force? However, both Luke and Obi-Wan saw through the trick in seconds. Palpatine almost certainly tells Anakin to kill Ahsoka and Maul, but he hesitates. Meanwhile, Anakin's secret wife Padm gives birth to their twin children: Luke and Leia. This Star Wars theory is compelling, but it's also, like many real-life conspiracy theories, trying to explain why things fall apart without much evidence. Perhaps Sidious had someone in mind to rule in his place in the interim. The Prequels established Anakin Skywalker as a uniquely powerful Force-user, with a Midichlorian count that exceeded even Master Yoda. What is certain, however, is that Darth Sidious sought to live forever, and explored countless different avenues in his quest for immortality. The Clone Wars might eventually end, but it could drag on for far longer, devastating the galaxy. THEORY THURSDAY - Today we dive deeper into the infamous opera scene when Palpatine reveals the story of Darth Plagueis to Anakin. Anakin would likely want to raise Luke and Leia, which would cause problems if the Jedi Order isnt reformed. Molded and shaped by external forces that amplified his latent dark inclinations, Anakin first killed in anger after the murder of his mother Shmi in Attack of the Clones. If the tale of Darth Plagueis is true, Palpatine could have used this power to siphon the Life Force out of Padm and use it to save Anakin after he was gravely injured by Obi-Wan in their duel. However, one intriguing new theory identifies a pattern in the way Lucasfilm has retconned the death of the galaxy's greatest villains to reveal the only Jedi who can beat Palpatine in Episode . Padame delivers twins and because Anakin is there and Palpatine isn't drawing her life force to save him, she lives. He knowingly sacrificed his life to do so. Fan Fictions are BACK! If it got too chaotic, maybe the ship would have crashed, thus killing the droids, Padme, and the unborn children, thus sending Vader spiraling out of control. Furthermore, it seems remarkably coincidental that Anakin Skywalker arrived just in time to hold his mother in his arms as she died. In Revenge of the Sith, after a now Sith Anakin Skywalker is defeated by his former master Obi-Wan Kenobi, he is taken by Palpatine to be put into his Darth Vader suit to save his life. Darth Sidious (Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace) Truly, the most powerful Sith Lord was Darth Sidious, better known in his public persona of Chancellor (later Emperor) Palpatine. Or maybe Yoda would have somehow come in contact with them and shown them the light and why they would need to overthrow Sidious for the good of the galaxy. I find it hard to believe that order 66 would have been enacted, not sure if Mas Amedda or anyone else close to the Chancellor knew of the protocols. Into the Sequel Trilogy era, Darth Sidious would presumably be just as interested in Kylo Ren and Rey, an ominous prospect forStar Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. Maybe Sidious drew on Anakin's fear to get the right appearance. A lifelong fan of major franchises including Star Wars, Doctor Who, and Marvel, Tom is delighted his childhood is back - and this time it's cool. Rey is often accused of being a Mary Sue, which is accurate to a . I highly doubt that Sidious would not have seen it coming. Have you ever wondered what the Star Wars story would be like if Anakin Skywalker the chosen one who was to. Whether or not Leia would have met Han Solo in this alternate scenario and eventually had a child with him is unknown, but the lack of one might have made events of the sequel era very different. This would suggest that Palpatine killed Plagueis, which has been a long-running theory within the "Star Wars" community. However, both Luke and Obi-Wan saw through the trick in seconds. However, in actual Star Wars canon, Palpatine never had a wife, or concubines or any children that we knew ofthat is, until The Rise of Skywalker revealed that he did somehow father children. Star Wars: Could Palpatine Have Wiped Out The Jedi WITHOUT Order 66? In any case, let us just assume the death of Obi-Wan Kenobi. Qui-Gon Jinn was one of the few Jedi who had dedicated a great deal of time to studying the ancient Jedi prophesies. Obi-Wan checks that she is breathing properly and even speaks with her on the ship after his duel with Anakin. And if Anakin killed Dooku, the Jedi's journey to the Dark Side would be well underway. Does Anakin kill Obi-Wan in Clone Wars? As both the Supreme Chancellor and the secret leader of the Separatists as,Darth Sidious, Palpatine already controlled the galaxy by the events of Revenge of the Sith, gradually turning the Republic into an autocratic regime through emergency powers given to him in response to the ever-growing Separatist threat. However, there is a popular theory (via Reddit) that posits that Padm did not die because she lost the will to live. Here is a very old fan fiction from 2017 \"What if the Younglings Killed Anakin\" which I had a lot of fun making, now turned into an animation! As Obi-Wan explained, "being a Jedi is not just about power, or lightsabers, or even skill with the Force. Who did Sheev Palpatine marry? Not only does it give Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith a more heartbreaking and tragic ending for Anakin and Padm, but it also provides a deeper and more sinister layer to the most notorious villain in Star Wars' galaxy far, far away. "Leia warned. How did Sheev Palpatine become evil? Marie Barros was born and raised in Canada. But whether it would have taken a short while or a long while, I have a feeling that Sidious and the Empire would have eventually found them, just as Krennic found the Ersos. type of questions. Next: Empire Strikes Back: Yoda & Obi-Wan's Advice To Luke Was Terrible. When he kills Obi-Wan with a strike of his lightsaber , Obi-Wan's entire body disappears, leaving only robes on the floor. The Star Wars franchise is filled with many "What if?" Star Wars' Plagueis Retcon Makes Anakin's Dark Side Fall Even More Tragic. But again, there is still the cloning on Exegol to consider. I would have to believe if that was the case then the Jedi Council would step in for some type of transition. "Leia replied. The only explanation given in Revenge of the Sith for Padms death is that because there is nothing wrong with her physically, she has lost the will to live after seeing Anakin turn to the Dark Side. As shown in both canon and Legends, however, Palpatine is capable of returning from the dead. Now, we have confirmation of when this actually happened. Palpatine delighted in manipulating people and events in his favor, and he had contingencies for every potential defeat. Right after Anakin becomes Darth Vader, Padm passes away, which according to a droid is because she lost the will to live. Many things would changeIn this video I go into a deep fan fiction on something that I think could happen in an alternate universe. Lucas decided it was a little too on-the-nose, and he ditched the dialogue. Plus, he is the Chosen One, so perhaps I am not giving him enough credit, and he could kill this Sith. Many Star Wars projects, including movies, are currently in the works, but none of them (as far as we know) are set to be the equivalent of Star Wars: Episode X. Therefore, if Palpatine were to either properly frame the Tusken Raiders for Shmi's kidnapping or go as far as to manipulate them, then maybe Palpatine was indeed behind everything. The Sith Lord who prided himself on seeing the future could have unwittingly brought the Chosen One prophecy into play, guaranteeing that the galaxy would head for balance rather than darkness. So let's speculate about what might have happened had Darth Vader defeated Obi-Wan. I hope you have a great day, and I'll see you in the next one! Sidious is someone who has contingencies, so he probably would have had his own agents in play trying to eliminate Vader in the case of his death. Padms death disappointed audiences when they saw Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith, but one theory posits that Palpatine was the one to kill Padm. However, a bigger issue for Anakin would be explaining his secret marriage to Padm and their children to the Jedi Order, who forbid such attachments (aside from rare exceptions, such as Ki-Adi-Mundi in Legends). Still, although the vision is not conclusive, it strongly supports the idea Anakin was created by Palpatine. ?Where is Snoke in all of this? However, one of the biggest problems audiences had with the film was Padms death. David Miller is a writer for Screen Rant, indie comic writer, and life-long lover of all things Star Wars, Marvel, and DC. While the Star Wars prequel trilogy was not originally welcomed by audiences, it is now experiencing a second chance. Jar Jar Binks is a fictional character of the Gungan race from the Star Wars saga created by George Lucas.Jar Jar appears throughout the Star Wars prequel trilogy - as a major character in Episode I: The Phantom Menace, with a smaller role in Episode II: Attack of the Clones, and with only a one-line cameo in Episode III: Revenge of the Sith - as well as having a role in the television . As for the Republic, I think that it would be split in two. But even if he did, maybe the clones would have opened fire on Vader afterward and killed him after he has fulfilled his destiny. Maybe the twins would have eventually teamed up against Sidious to take his place. RELATED:Star Wars Canon Already Explained How The Emperor Survived Return Of The Jedi. New Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews, Star Wars Theory: [SPOILER] Was Behind the Death of Anakin's Mother. Recently, she started a commentary series called Journey to No Way Home where Marie and her sister react to all the Spider-Man films. Vader denies it, saying he sensed Padm was still alive, which the audience knows she was as Obi-Wan escaped on the ship with her. Darth Vader wasn't the Emperor's only enforcer; but what happened to his Inquisitors? This is prior to him receiving the training to become a Force ghost, so Vader striking him down in this case might not have made the Jedi more powerful than he could have imagined. Let's analyze what one fan theory suggests, as well as its merits and level of possibility. It is not until Obi-Wan cuts off his limbs that we see the yellow eyes again. https://youtu.be/aSdW1e2USAMMusic - William Maytook This however does not hold much weight. RELATED:Star Wars 9 Confirms The Skywalker Saga Is Sheev Palpatine's Story. According to the junior novelization ofStar Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones, the Tusken Raiders took Shmi deliberately in order to goad the colonists into pursuing them, so they could launch a series of deadly traps. In light of what we know from canon, this type of ending seems highly unlikely. The relationship between a Sith Lord and their Apprentice is always fractious - the Rule of Two establishes that there should be one to crave power, and the other to wield it - but that seems to have been particularly the case with Palpatine, who never anticipated being supplanted by one of his students. The Empire did try to frame the Tusken Raiders in A New Hope for the murder of both Luke's aunt and uncle, as well as the Jawas. With many fan theories being further explored, this chilling theory about Palpatine orchestrating and carrying out Padms death is certainly one to take a closer look at. The Jedi came to assume that this meant the Chosen One was destined to destroy the Sith, and when the Clone Wars began they were eager to bring Anakin into play against the dark side. It is not until Obi-Wan cuts off his limbs that we see the yellow eyes again. The Tusken Raiders would not be so easy to mind control. "He killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin!" Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker. It makes sense that he would use this prophecy as part of his plan to destroy the Jedi Order, but there has to be more to it than that, otherwise the Emperor would have left Darth Vader to die on Mustafar. Star Wars: The Force Awakens SPOILER Discussion Thread Movies She is usually that person after watching anything who says, "that's not the way it was in the book" or "what if they had done this instead?" As mentioned before, Tusken Raiders have an advanced culture and are shrewd at bargaining. !Gaming Channel - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMI5ojH8j_CqftUjCjfgd-AWebsite - https://www.StarWarsTheory.comFacebook - https://www.facebook.com/starwarstheoryToos/Twitter - https://twitter.com/SWTheory66Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/star.wars.theory/?hl=enHats -https://shop.spreadshirt.com/SWTheoryPatreon - https://www.patreon.com/StarWarsTheoryDarth Vader ANNIHILATES Clone Troopers After Order 66 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BV2N-RUOajoHow Darth Vader Went to the Jedi Councils Secret Prisonhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13_CYZMt-y8\u0026t=15sWhy Didn't Obi-Wan Remember R2-D2? In Legends canon, Jedi have emerged from their ranks, such as Sharad Hett and A'Sharad Hett. It's certainly possible. RELATED: All Star Wars Movies, Ranked Worst To Best. Release date: May 16, 2002 Cast: Ewan McGregor, Natalie Portman, Hayden Christensen A few years later, Anakin is training as a Padawan under Obi-Wan Kenobi when the now Senator Padm Amidala's . He's been shown interacting with the Nightsisters, a dark side cult who have their own mystic ways of surviving death; learning from Lord Momin, an ancient Sith whose consciousness was preserved inside one of his Sith helmets; and he even researched clone technology in order to create new bodies to transfer his soul into. RELATED:Star Wars Legends: The Reign of Darth Krayt and the One Sith. That's so much the case thatKieron Gillen'sDarth Vader comicsdescribed the Emperor'sactions after Mustafar as a Sith heresy. Related: Star Wars' Plagueis Retcon Makes Anakin's Dark Side Fall Even More Tragic. We all know how the Galaxy unfolds with Anakin turning into the. He was born and raised in New York and has a degree in English from Rider University. A graduate of Edge Hill University, Tom remains strongly connected with his alma mater as a volunteer chaplain. Palpatine sought to corrupt that prophecy, by creating an ultimate weapon against the Jedi Order and a potential host that would allow him to tip the galaxy into eternal darkness. We will highlight this intense scene from The Revenge of the Sith novelization by Matthew Stover and I will . Even with his mistakes, Anakin would have left everything to be with Padm if he knew she was still alive. Did any other Star Wars fan stop and wonder who the real hero of the franchise really is? Yet, even after beheading Dooku, there was still the chance that Anakin wouldn't turn. According to the novel Darth Plagueis, young Palpatine first discovered the temptation of the Dark Side of the Force while collecting . Palpatine himself was Plageuis' apprentice, who killed him in his sleep. More likely, Palpatine probably would have wanted Vader to corrupt the crystal his own blue-bladed lightsaber, or perhaps even that of his former master. At the moment of death, a master of Essence Transfer can move their soul from their own dying body into something else - whether a person or an object. Earned my MFA from Fairleigh Dickinson University. He's heavily involved with his local church, and anyone who checks him out on Twitter will swiftly learn he's into British politics too.