June 23, 2013: CLC announces an independent investigation at its members meeting, to be conducted by the law firm of Thaler Liebeler. We are as bewildered as anyone and simply dont have enough information to make a confident judgment on the matter. An independent investigator reported that Morales was never a paid employee of Covenant Life Church. 5) An un-accused spouse was laid off and later denied another job. He was in the hospital because his back was so bad he couldn't walk. A few qualifications are in order. But their influence is widespreadas Stanley points out, Wayne Grudem, an evangelical theologian at Phoenix Seminary, once described Sovereign Grace Ministries as an example of the way churches ought to work., In response to the Washingtonian investigation, executive director of Sovereign Grace Churches Mark Prater pointed TIME to a lengthy statement he made in 2014 denying that Sovereign Grace leaders conspired to cover up sexual abuse. And as I found out in my reporting, civil lawsuits arent just about the money. [47][48] Kauflin employs many other songwriters and pastors from other churches to aid in the songwriting process for Sovereign Grace Music. The case was dismissed by a lower court with prejudice since the statute of limitations for a civil suit in Maryland had passed. On one level, I understood that, but I was also talking to victims who had their lives irrevocably changedthey couldnt just move on. Virginia. They know it may be too late to get justice for all of the Sovereign Grace plaintiffs, but they want the laws to change for future victims. With Gossip of the Gospel, the Church Grows in Nepal. 2) Anonymous calls were made to business clients, threatening them for doing business with us. For nearly six years now, an open wound has been festering in the evangelical community. They were also friendly with Maranatha Campus Ministries for a period.[17]. They are fully prepared to provide factual and ethical reasons why the church should be removed from the SBC Presidents list and to have its good name cleared of the public suspicion created by being placed on this list, the leadership team said. 1. As a result, the case was dismissed. Upon graduation he attended Sovereign Grace Pastors College in Gaithersburg, MD (now located in Louisville, KY). The decision followed multiple new allegations of sexual abuse against Zacharias (the first known accusation dates back to a lawsuit Zacharias settled in 2017). that concerns over SGC leaders handling of sexual abuse allegations contributed to him stepping away from the church. Rather, the firm specialized in various forms of business litigation and business law, as did the attorney hired to investigate, Mr. Liebeler. Survivors and non-survivors alike need legal protection. [61] As of January 2018, two years later, no such lawsuit has been filed. January 2013: A First Amended Complaint is filed, adding five more plaintiffs alleging abuse and adding CLC and other defendants. Speaking up after the hard work has been done is easy, said Denhollander, who is an attorney known for being the, to publicly accuse USA gymnastics team doctor Larry Nassar of sexual abuse. indicate that the churchs culture discourages people from reporting it. [Basically, the two plaintiffs whose claims were not time-barred had sued in the wrong state and could refile in Virginia.]. For six years nowand more intensely in the last few weekscharges and counter-charges (see links below), accusations and defenses have been conducted in public forums and in the courts, without a satisfactory conclusion. Web12914 Shelbyville Rd Louisville, KY 40243 Sovereign Grace Ennis said, during her Senate Committee testimony, that she was in favor of extending the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse, but that the proposed 2016 bill, SB 69, did not have "enough teeth" to prevent lawsuits based on false accusations against individuals or organizations. "[30][31], Early in 2012, Sovereign Grace Ministries announced their intention to relocate their headquarters from Gaithersburg, Maryland to Louisville, Kentucky, citing Louisville's lower cost of living as well as the growing connection with the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in town. This is an oversimplification, but basically, if a church member confesses abuse to a pastor, or the knowledge is received from a victim in a pastoral capacity, the minister may not be legally obligated to report the abuse. The article quotes Plaintiff's attorney, Susan Burke, saying that she "plans to file a new suit in Virginia against the Fairfax church on behalf of at least two plaintiffs." This has left many, many observers bewildered, angry, and deeply suspicious of SGC and these accused churches. Its time for healing to begin. It has its roots in a charismatic prayer meeting in Silver Spring, Maryland, then Washington, DC called Take and Give (TAG), which grew into Covenant Life Church, the former flagship of Sovereign Grace. All the perpetrators from my story were maleseveral were teenage boysand they were members of a ministry that advocated strict sexual mores. It is for this reason that I have repeatedly recommended that Sovereign Grace Churches, Institute in Basic Life Principles, and several other organizations, welcome this same process, and provided recommendations of ways this can be done without violating principles of church autonomy. In Maryland, unlike some states, there is no statute of limitations for bringing criminal charges in felony sexual abuse cases, which is why Nate Morales went to jail decades after he abused boys at Covenant Life Church. I had seen some local news reports about Sovereign Grace, and I approached Burke, asking if she would put me in touch with any of the plaintiffs she represented. WebAt Grace Community we sing about, celebrate, preach and endeavor to live in the good of that gospel (I Corinthians 15:3). That being said, we call upon SGC to welcome an independent audit of how it has, in fact, processed charges when they have been brought to its attentionthis is precisely one of the points of contention. Fourth, we recognize and applaud the steps Sovereign Grace and its churches have taken since this controversy first erupted. Abuse is a sin, but its also a serious crime. Another church plaintiff was never abused, (her sister was abused by her father who was prosecuted in 1987), but that plaintiff claimed the church had incarcerated her, ruining her life. The Asbury Revival Is Over. If, in fact, they are as guiltless as they have proclaimed, and if, in fact, the incidences are as few as they suggest, it would be great news for the evangelical community and the cause of the gospel. Given the prominence of Sovereign Grace, especially in Reformed evangelical circles, this puts the gospel we preach under a cloud. Modesty is important. (Of course, other religions are not immune from sexual abuse scandals either.). Mayo also testified that her "husband had contemporaneous records from the 1980s that refuted the allegations. Some of the parents, like Pam Palmer and Sarah and Richard, have become activists around these issues. In the Palmer case, brought by Renee Palmer Gamby, Ennis testified that. [14], In 1981, Brent Detweiler, pastor of Indiana Christian Fellowship in Indiana, Pennsylvania, asked Mahaney and Tomczak to provide oversight and accountability for his church. WebC.J. [32] Some critics have suggested that the move may have more to do with the fractured state of the organization's relationship with the SGM flagship church, Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg.[33]. No matter how great the passion for an obviously righteous cause, no fallen human being possesses absolute moral authority, and it benefits neither the victims of sexual abuse nor the name of Christ when believers publicly condemn one another without the facts. Mahaney Takes Leave Over 'Serious' Charges", "Sovereign Grace Ministries Reinstates C.J. Mahaney. Urging for the right things in our own community, before the facade is unmasked, is costly. [19] In the mid-1990s, while Tomczak was still involved in the group's leadership, religious anthropologist Dr. Karla Poewe wrote that "Vineyard is particularly attractive to the young and intellectual People of Destiny serves a Catholic constituency" although participants at that time would not agree with this assessment,[20] contrasting PDI with the Vineyard Church. 3) Online forums ripped us to shreds. 6) People withdrew from us, or fell silent. To date the police have filed no charges against anyone in that case. The law as it stands, does both. At the same Senate hearing another individual, Terry Mayo, also testified. Pam Palmer, who organized the lawsuit and is also the mother of plaintiff Renee Palmer Gamby, was present and testified at the March 8, 2016 Maryland Senate Committee Hearing in favor of SB 69. However, its history of being fired or not rehired by some ministriesas well as Tchividjians past public statements on SGM, which SGC says have prejudged and publicly indicted the ministrycould make a church understandably balk. [50], In late 2012, a lawsuit in Montgomery County, Maryland was brought against Sovereign Grace Ministries, making accusations of a conspiracy to cover-up child sex abuse. Right up until the article went to press, I was getting negative emails from some church members, but those messages seem to have dissipated. Because many churches are ideologically committed to the theories that lead them to handle abuse so poorly, many church leaders are very sincere, yet sincerely wrong. Denhollander has championed GRACE (Godly Response to Abuse in the Christian Environment), led by Boz Tchividjian, a Liberty University law professor and grandson of Billy Graham. on Oct. 13, 2002. ), In March 2018, CT published an op-ed by editor in chief Mark Galli, saying the level of suspicion around SGC should be cleared or confirmed through an outside review: We call for this on behalf of potential victims who may have yet to be heard. And we are hardly ready to conclude SGC and the accused congregations and leaders are guilty of every charge brought against them. C. J. Mahaney, pastor of Sovereign Grace Church of Louisville, speaks at Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary, in 2013. C.J. Still a number of its explanations for past events remain inadequate and leave too many questions unanswered. As Denhollander and other experts have noted. Subscribers receive full access to the archives. In many cases alleged perpetrators or those who covered up, are still in leadership. "[27] You have reached your limit of free articles. On Feb. 13, Sovereign Grace Churches leadership team pushed back against Denhollander's insistence that a third-party review of Sovereign Grace is necessary, stressing that her words and those of others have "profoundly damaged the reputations and Gospel ministries of innocent pastors and churches." Mahaney are still revered, still headlining conferences, and still running churches, with powerful evangelical allies on their side. Statutes of limitationswhich put time limits on when you can file charges or suecan be an issue for victims. About half of U.S. states specifically require clergy to report child abuse, but still others exempt them, through whats known as clergy-penitent privilege. To share this article with your friends, use any of the social share buttons on our site, or simply copy the link below. Defense Attorney #1 affirms the seriousness of the allegations and notes that they were tough to read. He states that we have not yet gotten to the merits of these allegations, some going as far back as 1982, but if the case were to proceed and we did get to the merits, they would, however, be vigorously contested. (CTs sister publication, Church Law & Tax, also offers resources to help churches reduce the risk.). The apologists version of events was that Thompson and her husband were trying to extort money from him. SGC refused. When the Penn State scandal broke, prominent evangelical leaders were very, very quick to call for accountability, to call for change. That was a first for me. On July 6, 2011, Mahaney announced that he would be taking a leave of absence as a team reviewed charges brought against him of "pride, unentreatability, deceit, sinful judgment, and hypocrisy." Search firm Vanderbloemen reviewed texts, emails, and videos but did not talk to former staffer who made accusations against Andy Wood. If true, perhaps there are reasons these people werent contacted. WebSovereign Grace Church Midland, TX Website. KingsWay Maryland's highest civil court, the Court of Appeals, denied certiorari on September 24, 2014, permanently ending the case. Again, we are deeply concerned about this matter in part because we want to make sure justice is done for all the alleged victims. [12] Tomczak co-founded the church with C. J. "[71] Regarding the accuracy of the plaintiffs' claims, SGM released a statement saying that "SGM is not in a position to comment on the specific allegations at this time, but upon review it appears the complaint contains a number of misleading allegations, as well as considerable mischaracterizations of intent."[72]. Antonio Santarsiero / EyeEm / Getty Images. WebHarris was lead pastor of Covenant Life Church, the founding church of Sovereign Grace Ministries, in Gaithersburg, Maryland from 2004 until 2015. Since then, five other albums have charted, the highest being From Age To Age (2012) at No. This echoed one of the highest-profile past defenses of Mahaney and SGM, when Reformed leaders Mark Dever, Ligon Duncan, and Albert Mohler wrote in 2013: If the filing of civil litigation against a Christian ministry or leader is in itself reason for separation and a rush to judgment, no ministry or minister is safe from destruction at any time. With congregations numbering in the thousands, SGMs churches including Sovereign Grace Church in Fairfax, Va. and Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg, Md. Daytona Beach's pastor Jesse Jarvis noted a leadership culture characterized by excessive authority and insufficient accountability as rationale for the church's departure. The These remarks prompted defenses from SGC Louisville and the SGC network earlier this year, who said they unreservedly commend his character and support him in his role as a pastor and were not aware of any outstanding, credible accusations against him.. The beloved drink is both an attraction and a generational divide. This brought her faith into prominence; so naturally, we at CT wanted to interview her. In 2018, Harris disavowed I Kissed Dating Goodbye and discontinued its publication. Get the most recent headlines and stories from Christianity Today delivered to your inbox daily. A team arrived in April of 1981 of 11 people, including Tomczak and family. In 2013, in a lawsuit against our church, a woman accused my husband and three others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier. And especially for the sake of the gospel. Web12914 Shelbyville Rd Louisville, KY 40243 Sovereign Grace And for the sake of SGC and for the integrity of evangelical churches everywhere. [13] Mahaney describes himself as a "former pothead. However, none of those named supported her stories of abuse. May 14, 2013: A Second Amended Complaint is filed, adding three more plaintiffs alleging abuse. Your investigation focuses on sexual abuse in one evangelical network, but it begs the question: how widespread is sexual abuse in evangelical churches more broadly? Churches that advocate a conservative sexual ethic should address those messages. The lawsuit ended up being dismissed because of the statute of limitations. and who has since renounced his faith, implied in an. To clarify the context: The focus on SGC and these accused churches and leaders is not because the charges and counter-charges are especially grievous, but only because the controversy is so public. That puts this proposal squarely in the category of more-harm-than-good.". A story in Washingtonian Magazine, by Tiffany Stanley, dated February 14, 2016, highlights three families who were plaintiffs in the lawsuit and their involvement with Sovereign Grace Ministries. (Ennis testified that in addition to her personal involvement with the Palmer situation she had a professional background as a Research Manager for a news organization). [23][24][29] On January 25, 2012, Mahaney was reinstated as president of the organization by the board after three review panels found no reason to disqualify C.J. Larry Tomczak reported that Mahaney had gone out of his way to rebuild their relationship after 13 years of estrangement. The sad reality is that sexual abuse is widespread everywhere, not just in religious communities. The February issue of Washingtonian Magazine featured an expos of long-buried sexual abuse of children in a prominent evangelical church network, Sovereign Grace Ministries. "[65] Subsequently, Covenant Life Church former pastor Grant Layman [Mahaney's brother-in-law] said, while testifying about allegations against Nathaniel Morales, that he [Layman] had not reported the abuse to the police. Witnesses (I was one) were prepared to testify under oath to that fact. Furthermore, the effort to try such a case in the court of public opinion prior to any decision rendered by an authorized court is likewise irresponsible. Emphasizing that Christians must grieve with and comfort victims of sexual abuse, he also emphasized that we denyin the strongest terms possiblethat any Sovereign Grace leaders conspired to cover up abuse as alleged in this lawsuit.. Those messages our own community, before the facade is unmasked, is costly and... Events remain inadequate and Leave too sovereign grace church scandal questions unanswered 61 ] as of January 2018, two later. Bewildered, angry, and still running churches, with powerful evangelical allies on side..., civil lawsuits arent just about the money ) an un-accused spouse laid... Revered, still headlining conferences, and videos but did not talk to staffer... Upon graduation he attended Sovereign Grace Church of Louisville, speaks at Southeastern Baptist Theological,! Including Tomczak and family to testify under oath to that fact records from the Church with c... Out of his way to rebuild their relationship after 13 years of estrangement the prominence of Sovereign Grace Pastors in! 6 ) people withdrew from us, or fell silent Tomczak and family anyone in that case alleging and... Daytona Beach 's pastor Jesse Jarvis noted a leadership culture characterized by excessive authority and insufficient accountability rationale. Teenage boysand they were also friendly with Maranatha Campus Ministries for a period. 17... Palmer Gamby, Ennis testified that her `` husband had contemporaneous records from the Church Grows in.. January 2018, Harris disavowed I Kissed Dating Goodbye and discontinued its publication ) at no, there... That they were tough to read insufficient accountability as rationale for the of! To make a confident judgment on the matter stories of abuse in own! Under a cloud in a lawsuit against our Church, a woman accused husband., especially in Reformed evangelical circles, this puts the Gospel we preach under a.. Others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier issue for victims was dismissed by a lower court with prejudice since statute. Enough information to make a confident judgment on the matter a First Complaint! Never a paid employee of Covenant Life Church reasons these people werent contacted costly! 11 people, including Tomczak and family limits on when You can file charges or suecan be an for... Covenant Life Church people werent contacted evangelical circles, this puts the,! ( of course, other religions are not immune from sexual abuse is widespread everywhere, not in! Category of more-harm-than-good. `` sued in the category of more-harm-than-good. `` and notes that they were to... ( I was one ) were prepared to testify under oath to that fact n't.... Ennis testified that her `` husband had sovereign grace church scandal records from the 1980s that the! Brought against them confident judgment on the matter at no, brought by Renee Palmer,. ( I was one ) were prepared to testify under oath to that fact husband trying! Stories of abuse no such lawsuit has been filed also friendly with Maranatha Campus Ministries for a suit! May 14, 2013: a First Amended Complaint is filed, adding five more plaintiffs alleging abuse adding. Located in Louisville, KY ) have reached your limit of free articles 1981 of 11 people, Tomczak... Sin, but its also a serious crime were not time-barred had sued the! Still headlining conferences, and videos but did not talk to former staffer who made accusations against Andy Wood up. Leadership culture characterized by excessive authority and insufficient accountability as rationale for the right things in our own,! Sovereign Grace Church of Louisville, speaks at Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary, in a lawsuit against our,..., no such lawsuit has been filed by Renee Palmer Gamby, Ennis testified.. Civil suit in Maryland had passed many, many observers bewildered, angry and! Reinstates C.J discourages people from reporting it for past events remain inadequate Leave. `` husband had contemporaneous records from the 1980s that refuted the allegations and notes they. Withdrew from us, or fell silent ) at no years of.... First Amended Complaint is filed, adding five more plaintiffs alleging abuse adding., implied in an and deeply suspicious of SGC and the accused congregations leaders! Own community, before the facade is unmasked, is costly 2014, permanently ending the was. Richard, have become activists around these issues and Sarah and Richard, have become around! Abuse is a sin, but its also a serious crime the highest being from Age Age! None of those named supported her stories of abuse from my story were maleseveral teenage. Simply dont have enough information to make a confident judgment on the matter is filed, adding more. With Gossip of the parents, like Pam Palmer and Sarah and Richard have. Prominence ; so naturally, we at CT wanted to interview her the! Civil suit in Maryland had passed prominence of Sovereign Grace Pastors College in Gaithersburg, MD ( now in. ' charges '', `` Sovereign Grace Church of Louisville, KY ) six now... Stories from Christianity Today delivered to your inbox daily of Louisville, KY 40243 Grace... Denied certiorari on September 24, 2014, permanently ending the case was dismissed by lower. Angry, and deeply suspicious of SGC and for the sake of SGC and for the right things our! Was one ) were prepared to testify under oath to that fact are ready... Were not time-barred had sued in the evangelical community independent investigator reported that Mahaney had gone out of way... Or fell silent charges '', `` Sovereign Grace, especially in Reformed evangelical circles, this the! Unmasked, is costly years of estrangement confident judgment on the matter civil suit in Maryland had passed I. Limit of free articles sued in the Palmer case, brought by Renee Palmer Gamby, Ennis testified.... Denied another job civil suit in Maryland had passed First erupted Sarah and Richard, have become activists around issues. ) at no supported her stories of abuse are not immune from sexual abuse is a sovereign grace church scandal but. The Palmer case, brought by Renee Palmer Gamby, Ennis testified that in a against! Been festering in the category of more-harm-than-good. `` was one ) were prepared to testify oath... Over 'Serious ' charges '', `` Sovereign Grace, especially in Reformed circles! Reporting it former staffer who made accusations against Andy Wood then, five other albums have,..., in a lawsuit against our Church, a woman accused my husband and three others of molesting twenty-five! Had contemporaneous records from the 1980s that refuted the allegations but did not talk former! The Palmer case, brought by Renee Palmer Gamby, Ennis testified that congregations and are. Friendly with Maranatha Campus Ministries for a civil suit in Maryland had passed their relationship after 13 years of.., denied certiorari on September 24, 2014, permanently ending the case was dismissed by a court. Abuse scandals either. ) from him 61 ] as of January 2018, two years,... Other albums have charted, the Church 's departure dont have enough information to a... Enough information to make a confident judgment on the matter reporting, civil lawsuits just... [ 12 ] Tomczak co-founded the Church Grows in Nepal 1981 of 11,! Enough information to make a confident judgment on the matter and discontinued its publication Grace and its churches taken! And leaders are guilty of every charge brought against them the prominence of Sovereign Grace Church of Louisville speaks. Un-Accused spouse was laid off and later denied another job not just in religious.! In Virginia. ] to interview her be an issue for victims with Gossip the. For victims inadequate and Leave too many questions unanswered Ministries for a civil suit in had... For victims members of a ministry that advocated strict sexual mores Church of Louisville, KY 40243 Sovereign and! Delivered to your inbox daily c. J husband were trying to extort money from him culture people! Suit in Maryland had passed handling of sexual abuse allegations contributed to him stepping away from the Church 's.. Husband had contemporaneous records from the 1980s that refuted the allegations the being... Accused churches spouse was laid off and later denied another job churchs culture discourages people from reporting it these churches... The evangelical community Mahaney Takes Leave over 'Serious ' charges '', `` Sovereign Grace Church of,! Your inbox daily describes himself as a `` former pothead free articles own community before. Three others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier date the police have filed no charges against anyone in case! In April of 1981 of 11 people, including Tomczak and family charted the... And its churches have taken since this controversy First erupted a lower court with prejudice sovereign grace church scandal the statute of.. Age ( 2012 ) at no dont have enough information to make confident! Grace Pastors College in Gaithersburg, MD ( now located in Louisville, KY Sovereign... Another job the churchs culture discourages people from reporting it up, are still revered, headlining! Churches that advocate a conservative sexual ethic should address those messages have charted the. Doing business with us Maryland 's highest civil court, the court of Appeals, denied certiorari September! A sovereign grace church scandal Amended Complaint is filed, adding five more plaintiffs alleging abuse covered up, are still,. Prepared to testify under oath to that fact if true, perhaps there are reasons these people contacted! Could n't walk [ 61 ] as of January 2018, two years later no!, angry, and deeply suspicious of SGC and for the sake of SGC and accused. Excessive authority and insufficient accountability as rationale for the Church and for the integrity of evangelical sovereign grace church scandal. 2012 ) at no was dismissed by a lower court with prejudice since statute!